Skip Navigation
Posts
40
Comments
28
Joined
2 yr. ago
Music @lemmy.studio
favrion @lemmy.studio

What artists currently in the cultural zeitgeist (or less than 25 years famous) do you predict will be inducted in their first year of eligibility for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame?

My guesses are as follows: Ariana Grande, Lady Gaga, Harry Styles, Queen Bey, Kanye, Pink, Justin Timberlake, Justin Bieber, Billie Eilish, Lorde, Grimes, XXXTENTACION, Taylor Swift, Olivia Rodrigo.

Chord Progressions @lemmy.studio
favrion @lemmy.studio

Favorite chord progression of the year?

Chord Progressions @lemmy.studio
favrion @lemmy.studio

Eurythmics - Winter Wonderland

This is clearly not the original version, but it doesn't sway my point. This song, in all renditions, begins in one key in the verses and changes key twice during the chorus, ascending by two whole tones and then one whole tone. In this Eurythmics version, the verses are in G major, the first two lines of the chorus are in B major, and the last two lines of the chorus are in D major. The song ends in G major.

It's almost like the excitement level ramps up as the singer talks about getting married. Notably, there are no minor chords in this song, which makes it feel artificially happy, which to me makes sense because this song is whimsical.

But what I find most fascinating is the transitions. We jump from G major straight to B major: the G descends to F# while the D ascends to D# and the B stays put. Then we jump right into D major: the F# remains as the D# descends to D and the B descends to A. Then we have a V-I to G again to restart the cycle.

Illustrated: G B D/ F# B D#/ F# A D

Music @beehaw.org
favrion @lemmy.studio

What are some mistakes that were left in songs? Do you have a favorite?

Music @beehaw.org
favrion @lemmy.studio

DEVO went lo-fi ambient? Is this a Spotify goof?

What do you think of their latest singles, assuming that it really is DEVO being as anti-DEVO as possible? This stumped me. If it really is DEVO, then this is absolutely genius because it's almost like they're aware that people don't listen to DEVO or their messages, so they don't want to be DEVO.

https://open.spotify.com/track/23UbddBFEMzyVV5QzX8FW0?si=PDsWrb3PShW0H1OAydRRsw

https://open.spotify.com/track/5hTcwQSqajE5wruijdqsSU?si=_Z9Ck4DxT0qucsDCm0R9Vg

Music @beehaw.org
favrion @lemmy.studio

When, in your opinion, does a modern rock song expire into a classic rock song?

A: 15 years B: 20 years C: 25 years D: 30 years E: 40 years F: 50 years G: other

Music @beehaw.org
favrion @lemmy.studio

What are your least favorite modern music cliches?

Some for me are when they do an uplifting key change at the end (a phenomenon which has existed for decades,) when they use too much tape wear effect to make it purposefully warbly for no good reason, when they lower the pitch of a singer's voice by an octave, and when the song just ends with no finality like the tape was cut (unless it's part of a progressive rock album.)

Music @beehaw.org
favrion @lemmy.studio

What is the earliest not-jazz song that featured a longwinded instrumental section in the middle a la "Light My Fire" by The Doors or "Money" by Pink Floyd? - lemmy.studio

Music @lemmy.studio
favrion @lemmy.studio

What is the earliest not-jazz song that featured a longwinded instrumental section in the middle a la "Light My Fire" by The Doors or "Money" by Pink Floyd?

Chord Progressions @lemmy.studio
favrion @lemmy.studio

Talking Heads - Stay Up Late

The verses have a progression of A, G, F, E, and the choruses go A, G, E.

I think that the verses are subtly clever because A leads to E in a I V I motion, but in A Mixolydian, G is part of the scale, and I think that descending to F#m would make it sound too "major." So they opt for F instead, which is a half step above E, the target. You still have the line cliche, but with that Talking Heads wit thrown in. I also find it fascinating that, in root position, we have the backwards alphabet in the fifths (E D C B A) with F and G occurring in the root notes during the sequence. The song is about the absurdity of being an infant, so it makes sense.

A C# E / G B D / F A C / E G# B

Chord Progressions @lemmy.studio
favrion @lemmy.studio

Devo - Gut Feeling

E5 (Em?), G, C, A, D, E5... are the chords to mostly the entire song until the outro sticks to D5, C5, D5 to the end. My question is: what is the key center? Assuming E5 is a stand-in for Em, we have the following options:

E: i III VI IV bVII i... or i III VI V/bVII bVII G: vi I IV ii V vi... or vi I IV V/V V C: iii V I VI II iii... or iii V I V/ii II A: v bVII bIII I IV v... D: ii IV bVII V I...

I am leaning toward G personally because it looks the most natural with Roman numeral analysis in mind. Thoughts?

Music @beehaw.org
favrion @lemmy.studio

What is the highest pitched scream or growl or shriek that you have heard in a song?

Chord Progressions @lemmy.studio
favrion @lemmy.studio

Justice - D.A.N.C.E

The intro has the following progression: A E / F#m E / D B / E (2x) > D / Dm / C#m Cm / B7

This precedes a line cliche chorus: line cliche of F#m, E, D#m, D

Then we have a bridge with a jazzy twist: F#m / E / D#m7 / Dadd9, E7add6/D

It took me multiple listens to constrict the bridge chords namely due to that last chord. I didn't hear an F or an F# but it was definitely over D, so that was my best guess based on E's relationship with the tonic, which I believe is F# in F# minor. A couple of intriguing points:

1: The V/VII in the intro to a dance hit? Mesmerizing.

2: The diminished sounding bridge with the VII7 adds some spice to the track.

Music @beehaw.org
favrion @lemmy.studio

Have you ever heard a singer whose voice sounded like yours?

I once heard Cool Song #2 by MGMT without headphones and thought that it sounded like my voice until I listened closer.

  • What is the benefit of this tuning?

  • Music @beehaw.org
    favrion @lemmy.studio

    What is the best unorthodox guitar tuning?

    Chord Progressions @lemmy.studio
    favrion @lemmy.studio

    The Beach Boys - 'Til I Die

    The chord progression is mellow and traipsing, yet a bit unsettling.

    Abmaj7, Bb6, C, Bb6, C, Dmadd9/F, Esus4/B, Cmaj7, Emadd9, Gmaj7

    Music @beehaw.org
    favrion @lemmy.studio

    Any songs where it's amazing or perfect... except for that one part that sticks out like a sore thumb?

    Chord Progressions @lemmy.studio
    favrion @lemmy.studio

    Any weird chord progressions that you have heard lately?

    Music @beehaw.org
    favrion @lemmy.studio

    What would you describe as proto-emo music?

    Chord Progressions @lemmy.studio
    favrion @lemmy.studio

    What are your thoughts on the obscure naming systems used by Ian Ring for scales, namely the Zeitler and Dozenal scales?

  • Another One Bites the Dust by Queen, Good Times by Chic, Money by Pink Floyd, Feel Good Inc by The Gorillas... all that Top 40 stuff is usually recommended. I want something different.