cross-posted from: https://links.hackliberty.org/post/665784

Some Lemmy instances (e.g. Beehaw) do not support down votes for whatever reason. When an instance does support down votes, authors often get zero feedback with the down votes, which ultimately supports a communities of haters. I’ve noticed some communities struggle to get content because of some malicious down voters who just down vote every post to discourage activity and effectively sabotage the community.

The fix:

An instance admin should be able to flip a switch that requires every down vote to collect a 1-line rationale from the voter. These one-liners should be visible to everyone on a separate page. Upvotes do not need raionale.

Perhaps overkill, but it might be useful if a moderator can cancel or suppress uncivil down votes.

cross-posted from: https://links.hackliberty.org/post/664960

It would be useful to have more refined control over participation in a group. Someone should be able to create a group that gives permissions to specific individuals. A variety of permissions would be useful:

• permission to see that a community/mag exists (some groups may or may not want to be listed in searchable a public directory)
• permission to read the posts in a community/mag
• permission to vote in the community/mag
• permission to start a new thread in the community/mag
• permission to comment on an existing thread in the community/mag

A forum creator should be able to set the above perms on:

• individual accounts
• all users on an instance (e.g. users on an instance @weH8privacy.com might be unfit for voting and writing comments in the community “fightForPrivacy”)
• all users not on an instance (e.g. local users only [for example](https://github.com/LemmyNet

cross-posted from: https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/post/6251633

LemmyWorld is a terrible place for communities to exist. Rationale:

• Lemmy World is centralized by disproportionately high user count
• Lemmy World is centralized by #Cloudflare
• Lemmy World is exclusive because Cloudflare is exclusive

It’s antithetical to the #decentralized #fediverse for one node to be positioned so centrally and revolting that it all happens on the network of a privacy-offender (CF). If #Lemmy World were to go down, a huge number of communities would go with it.

So what’s the solution?

Individual action protocol:

1. Never post an original thread to #LemmyWorld. Find a free world non-Cloudflare decentralized instance to start new threads. Create a new community if needed. (there are no search tools advanced enough to have a general Cloudflare filter, but #lemmyverse.net is useful because it supports manually filtering out select nodes like LW)
2. Wait for some engagement, id