"What is a woman?"

You're viewing part of a thread.

Show Context

265 comments

No, I'm not. Saying gender must be perfomed to the traditional binary in order to be recognized as the gender you state is exactly what Republicans are arguing with their genital inspections.
They look at a woman or man and say "that's not woman or man enough!" This thinking is inappropriate and leads to abuse like genital inspections. We are not entitled to placing gender onto someone else. We accept it from the other person as they define it.
Sure, we might project our experience of gender onto someone and assume their gender. But that doesn't mean our projection is the reality of what gender must be for that person.
- Okay, so is your argument that the definition SHOULD change so that Republicans cannot inspect genitals?
  
  My argument with you is that women should be defined as anyone who identifies or feels like a woman.
  My opinion on gender gatekeeping is that the gender binary is heuristic nonsense and we should do away with it in general. We do not need to act as gender police or support the notion that society should police gender or self expression.
  
  women should be defined as anyone who identifies or feels like a woman.
  So you are prescribing it.
  I don't respect the intention behind trying to force others to use your language. This is a large part of why the conservatives are so angry.
  
  This is a large part of why the conservatives are so angry.
  Conservatives are angry because M&Ms have different boots on than they used to, I really don't care, man.
  
  Lol the conservatives are angry because they are entitled dickwads being told no. And if you empathize with that, well... Kinda seems like a veiled threat to me that if I don't cater to your stupid man feelings, you'll put me in my place. Well, I'm a lil too intellectually dangerous for that one and youre a giant coward so whatever. The conservatives are NO where near as angry as the women. There are many simultaneous movements happening including 4B as a reaction to men's abuse towards women. And it's time women started to make men feel our anger. We aren't your mommies. Women are the keeper of cultures. It's time to flex that. Let society bend or break.
  And let's point out that you're the one who insists (prescribes) a basis for what a woman is other than this definition. You think society should prescribe and define gender for individuals, not the other way around.
  Yeah, I have opinions. My opinion is that the definition for woman should be the above because it is the most inclusive of all types of women. That makes it a good definition because it's accurate.
  
  I didn't threaten you.
  You're being hyperbolic.
  
  I think the word you actually want to use is hysterical, not hyperbolic.
  https://www.plannedparenthood.org/planned-parenthood-south-east-north-florida/blog/the-history-of-hysteria-and-how-it-impacts-you
  
  What I think you're doing is exaggerating, synonymous with hyperbole.
  
  What I think you're doing is misogyny and gaslighting.
  
  I think that is more hyperbole.

265 comments